
The Icelandic filmmaker and visual artist Hlynur Pálmason requires his audience to put in some effort—not a lot, but enough to force you to pay close attention—in order to make sense of the domestic dynamic at work within the family unit at the center of his movie The Love That Remains. The film’s scope takes in a full year during which we notice the seasons pass, but the structure is episodic so home truths can only be understood through patterns of behavior. Moreover, Pálmason often tosses in non sequiturs and fantasy sequences that can throw the viewer off the scent of his narrative quarry.
In the beginning, the only thing that’s clear is that the couple involved, a visual artist named Anna (Saga Garðarsdöttir) and a long haul fisherman named Magnús (Sverrir Gudnason), have decided to end their marriage, and that both will continue to live in their rural Icelandic community so that Magnús can be close to their three children—twin boys and a teenage girl, all of whom are played by Pálmason’s own kids—and the family dog, Panda. Though the split is an amicable one, Anna and Magnús seem incompatible from the get-go. She’s an earthy, outgoing artist with a worldly sensibility, and he’s a simple working man who is nonetheless insecure in his masculinity. A running joke has him constantly hitting her up for sex that she withholds for one offhanded reason or another (“It would confuse the kids”). But Pálmason’s main method of demonstrating this incompatibility is to show them at work. Magnús spends months at a time on a big boat surrounded by other men insecure in their masculinity while Anna attends to her abstract environmental art mostly by herself. In one extended sequence she entertains a pompous Swedish art dealer with superhuman patience before seeing him off with a muttered “Asshole!” The children, meanwhile, seem to do alright without Magnús around, which isn’t surprising since he wasn’t around that much when he was married to their mother, and it eventually becomes obvious that Anna gave birth to their first child when they were teens.
Much of the mood is light, even comical, especially in the dream sequences that are usually staged at Magnús’s expense. The ending, which finds Magnús mourning the passing of his role as paterfamilias in a particularly bizarre manner, doesn’t provide much in the way of closure. As a chronicle of connubial disintegration, The Love That Remains is perhaps overly coy in its attempt to prove a point, but it’s also beautifully shot (the landscape is bare and treacherously gorgeous) and disarmingly honest about what a family is all about.

The photography of the rural setting in the Spanish documentary Good Valley Stories is equally lovely but the effect is entirely different, since the setting is the stories. Director Jose Luis Guerín has always been interested in Barcelona and here focuses on an isolated pocket of humanity located just outside the city in a valley called Vallbona that has mostly been overlooked by the authorities owing to historical and bureacratic happenstance. Vallbona is surrounded on one side by a river, on another side by a major highway, and on a third side by a railway. The people who have settled within this triangle are mostly outsiders who have built their own homes and live a subsistence existence when they aren’t commuting to the city for work. As the opening titles explain it, Vallbona developed as “people from the South arrived,” and by “south” he doesn’t just mean the south of Spain.
Guerín filmed for more than three years, during which the area underwent drastic changes due to new development that displaced many residents, forcing some to abandon their makeshift dwellings and move into state-run apartment complexes. In addition, many of the vegetable and flower gardens that had been attended by generations of immigrants were appropriated for the construction of a new railway passage. Guerín samples the multi-ethnic community in a manner so casual that it’s apparent some scenes were staged for their poignancy and aesthetic impact (an idyllic sequence showing residents enjoying a communal day at the canal is interrupted by shouts that “the cops are coming,” but after everyone flees only Guerín remains and no police show up). And while he shows effectively how disparate cultures can maintain their distinctive lifestyles while adapting to native mores and languages, he seems more interested in their mutual loss of a sense of place, mostly through the stories of the community’s elders, who have been here since the 40s when Franco’s shadow was still a threat. Certainly the most entertaining and edifying scenes are those in which these elders discuss everything from the French revolution to the delicacy of small-plot agriculture over good food and alcohol. Scripted? I wouldn’t be surprised, but I also wouldn’t change a thing.
In the end, Guerín seems to be saying, the world can’t be denied. The newest refugees are Russians and Ukrainians, united not only by a linguistic bond but by their sense of uprootedness on account of a war they could only escape. To them, Villbona is paradise, and not just because of the absence of daily strife. They seem to have stumbled upon it and in doing so believe they’ve won the lottery.
The Love That Remains, in Icelandic and English, now playing in Tokyo at Human Trust Cinema Yurakucho (03-6259-8608), Shinjuku Musashinokan (03-3354-5670), Yebisu Garden Cinema (0570-783-715).
Good Valley Stories, in Spanish, Catalan, Arabic, French, Portuguese, Russian, Hindi, and African dialects, now playing in Tokyo at Human Trust Cinema Shibuya (03-5468-5551).
The Love That Remains home page in Japanese
Good Valley Stories home page in Japanese
The Love That Remains photo (c) Still Vivid, Snowglobe, Hobab, Maneki Films, Film I Vast, Arte France Cinema
Good Valley Stories photo (c) 2025 Orfeo Iluso – Perspective Films – 3CAT – Los Ilusos Films – Los Films de Orfeo












