
After It Was Just an Accident won the Palme d’Or at last year’s Cannes, its director, Jafar Panahi, accompanied it to many other film festivals, including Busan, where I first saw it in September and which honored Panahi with its Asian Filmmaker of the Year award. The movie was even nominated for a Best International Feature Oscar, albeit under the auspices of France rather than the country where it was made and set, Iran, which would never have submitted it for consideration, and Panahi was there in Los Angeles for the ceremony. Reportedly, he is back in his home country just as the regime that hates him so much is at war with Donald Trump. It’s a situation that’s difficult to comprehend. Panahi has been jailed at least twice for his films and forbidden from making any since 2010, and yet he has continued to do so in an underground fashion without defecting like so many other Iranian filmmakers who provoked the ire of the regime. Even more remarkable, Accident is, unlike the other samizdat movies he’s made, a pure fiction feature with full production values, and while it is obviously at least partially based on his own experience, Panahi has designed it as a generalized entertainment that is unsparing in its indictment of the regime as an organ of abject cruelty. He has said that he must return to Iran because his family is there. He refuses to abandon the country that made him, but, given what we know of the government, why it did not simply throw him in prison the moment he re-entered in the spring is a mystery that deserves an exploration with its own movie.
The accident of the title is almost treated as a non sequitur. A man, his pregnant wife, and his very young daughter are traveling at night through a sparsely inhabited area when their car accidentally hits and kills a dog. The girl is distressed and the mother tries to allay her sadness by saying it is all God’s plan, to which the child irreverently replies, “God had nothing to do with it!” Shortly thereafter, the car breaks down, though it’s not clear if the malfunction has anything to do with the dog. Nevertheless, the driver (Ebrahim Azizi) pulls into a small factory, where an employee offers to look at the car, and while he does, the employee’s co-worker, Vahid (Vahid Mobasseri), overhears them and freezes in his tracks, recognizing something about the driver that upsets him greatly. His colleague directs the driver to an actual auto repair shop. Vahid follows and kidnaps him, believing him to be the man he and his fellow political prisoners called Eghbal, an infamous interrogator who tortured them in detention while they were masked and thus couldn’t see his face. While Vahid prepares to bury him alive in the desert, the driver insists he is not the man Vahid thinks he is, and Vahid has second thoughts.
From that point, the story becomes a tense comedy of errors, as Vahid attempts to confirm the driver’s identity with the help of other former prisoners who also were Eghbal’s victims. The roster of names that would like to see Eghbal dead grows, with each new addition adding to the confusion, since, for the most part, they are working on pure resentment rather than logic, and their memories, shaped by pain and fear, can hardly be called reliable. Add to this volatile, very loud mix an interrupted wedding rehearsal, a run-in with some police who demand a bribe (they even have their own credit card reader), and some more car trouble (which seems to be the movie’s leitmotif), and what you get is a tale that’s as relentless in its takedown of the regime’s self-servingly stupid methodology as it is plain about how that methodology has rendered the populace a churning mass of paranoid hatred. The ridiculousness of some of the dialogue and the almost slapstick story development do not diminish the intensity, and the penultimate scenes when the truth is revealed are the most savage that Panahi has ever realized. Though not as incendiary as Mohammad Rasoulof’s The Seed of the Sacred Fig, another Cannes winner that enraged the Iranian government, It Was Just an Accident is less pulpy and more dramatically incisive. Rasoulof, it should be noted, now lives in exile, while Panahi does not. Go figure.
In Persian. Opens May 8 in Tokyo at Shinjuku Piccadilly (050-6861-3011), Human Trust Cinema Yurakucho (03-6259-8608), Bunkamura Le Cinema Shibuya Miyashita (050-6875-5280).
It Was Just an Accident home page in Japanese
photo (c) LesFilmsPelleas












