Here are the album reviews I wrote for the March issue of EL Magazine, which was distributed in Tokyo earlier this week.

Le voyage dans la lune
-Air (Virgin/EMI)
The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo
-Trent Reznor & Atticus Ross (Null/Pachinko)
Pop artists have been doing movie soundtracks for years, but they usually leave the pop at home, since the whole point of a soundtrack is to intensify or otherwise add something to the mood depicted on screen. The French electro-pop duo Air has written a soundtrack for a restored, hand-colored version of Georges Melies’s silent masterpiece A Trip to the Moon. (If you don’t know anything about that film, check out Martin Scorsese’s Hugo—reviewed elsewhere in this issue—for a full description) The playful, experimental nature of Melies’s movie affords Jean-Benoit Dunckel and Nicolas Godin leeway in terms of form, and the light touch they’ve demonstrated on their dedicated pop albums is an appropriate fit. The opening two cuts, however, seem very literal-minded; less soundtrack music than soundtrack commentary. Victoria Legrand of Beach House sings, “How long will it take you to reach the stars?”, a remark that sounds unnecessary, and then there’s a guy with a very official-sounding voice counting down to liftoff. From there, it’s one spacey track after another, featuring loose keyboard runs and sci-fi sound effects. Dunckel and Godin have too much experience as entertainers to let the opportunity slip, and for the most part it’s a fun, riff-filled ride, until Au Revoir Simone comes in with a second vocal performance meant to close the proceedings. Clearly, Air conceived of the project as more along the lines of a suite—a record album—than a soundtrack. In that regard, Melies’s film becomes the visual complement to the album, playing behind Air on the backdrop as they perform on stage. But if you buy the deluxe version, which includes a DVD of the movie, you get the complete experience, and Milies, pardon the pun, blows Air away. The opening cut on Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross’s soundtrack album for David Fincher’s version of The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo (also reviewed in this issue), has the Yeah Yeah Yeahs’ Karen O tearing into Led Zeppelin’s “Immigrant Song,” but it’s used for a very impressive credit sequence, so who blows who away is difficult to tell. After that, the formula is similar to the one the duo provided for Fincher’s The Social Network, a work that won them an Oscar and revolutionized the art of soundtrack production. Though unobtrusive when accompanying Fincher’s visuals, Reznor/Ross’s treated mood music stands by itself very well, though you have to be a real fan of mood music to sit through this whole album, which clocks in at three hours, or more than 30 minutes longer than the movie itself. Apropos the suspense/mystery subject matter of the movie, the music is mostly ominous in tone and Reznor only occasionally exercises the sort of bombast he’s famous for. Some passages are so tense and unsettling you think to yourself, “I’ve just got to see this movie,” and that’s the measure of a successful soundtrack album. Continue reading










